How to fill out an I-9 with an Lawful Pemanent Resident Card
If the employee notes that they are “A lawful permanent resident,” option 3 in Section I then they need to enter the number highlighted in the image below on the front of the card.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9b32b/9b32bc048c0f211f1a89c78b77074094958a6c39" alt=""
Then the manager needs to select “2. Perm Pas Card or Alien Reg Receipt Card(Form I-551) from the List A drop-down menu. They will then need to enter the number on the back of the card as highlighted in the example above.